Series

Blogs

FRAND at the UK Supreme Court: Optis v Apple

fintech_bright lights_led_pink strobes.jpg
Article|
6 July 2026

​

Outlook

While the outcome is to be seen, the character of the Court's questioning suggests that several of Apple's arguments, on comparables methodology, the limits of appellate fact-finding, and the relevance of limitation periods, were received with genuine interest and, at times, apparent sympathy. The Court returned repeatedly to the evidential constraint under which the Court of Appeal worked (having reviewed a fraction of the trial materials) and to the commercial logic of limitation periods. 

The stakes extend well beyond the two parties. The Court of Appeal's implied aggregate 4G royalty stack is approximately $40 per device, against (according to Apple) approximately $6 implied by the first-instance determination in this case and by the Court of Appeal's ruling in InterDigital. The Supreme Court's guidance on FRAND comparables methodology, the weight owed to first-instance findings of fact, the role of limitation periods in SEP licences, and the relationship between English FRAND determinations and parallel foreign proceedings will shape SEP licensing across mobile telecommunications and every adjacent sector that is subject to standardisation. For those operating in this space, whether as implementers, SEP holders or platform administrators, the judgment will provide important clarity on how the English courts approach global FRAND rate-setting and will feed directly into licensing negotiations across the industry. Judgment is expected late 2026 / early 2027.

​

​