Series
Blogs
Series
Blogs
The Nigerian Supreme Court, in a judgment delivered on 6 March 2026 in Emerging Markets Telecommunications Services Limited v. Afdin Ventures Limited & 6 Ors (SC/CV/1096/2024), upheld the recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award against a non-signatory, unanimously rejecting arguments that the doctrine of privity precluded non-signatories from being bound by arbitration agreements and awards (the “Judgment”).
The underlying dispute arose from an investment transaction governed by an Offer of Terms and a Custodial Agreement, both containing arbitration clauses. Emerging Markets Telecommunications Services Limited (“EMTS”) was not a party to either agreement. Afdin Ventures Limited and another (together, the “Claimants”) commenced an action against EMTS and five other companies (together, the “Defendants”) at the Federal High Court seeking to recover USD 43,330,950 paid under the underlying agreements. The Defendants subsequently obtained an order referring the dispute to a sole arbitrator in accordance with the arbitration clauses.
The sole arbitrator delivered a partial award on jurisdiction and later rendered a final award, directing EMTS and two other defendants to refund the USD 43,330,950 to the Claimants. The Claimants then filed a recognition and enforcement application at the Federal High Court, which granted the application. EMTS appealed, but the Court of Appeal dismissed its appeal, affirming the Federal High Court's decision. EMTS then appealed to the Supreme Court (the “Court”).
The main question for determination was whether the final award could be recognised and enforced against EMTS as a non-signatory to the underlying agreements. The Court upheld the decisions of both lower courts, extending the arbitration agreements and award to EMTS.
The Court highlighted consent as the basis for arbitral jurisdiction, noting that consent may be express, implied or inferred from the parties’ conduct. It relied on the definition of ‘party’ in the Nigerian arbitration legislation, which includes "any person claiming through or under a party”. It also drew on comparative arbitral jurisprudence recognising several doctrines — including assignment, agency, equitable estoppel, alter ego, and the ‘group of companies’ doctrine — by which arbitration agreements may be extended to non-signatories.
It summarised that (as a matter of Nigerian law) the jurisdictional foundation for binding non-signatories lay in three interrelated pillars: the intention of the parties; whether there was benefit and burden accruing or accruable to a party under the agreement; and the principle of fairness and avoidance of injustice.
Applying these principles, the Court rejected EMTS’ arguments that the award was invalid because EMTS was a non-signatory. It adopted a facts-first approach, noting that Nigerian courts would not sit on appeal over findings of fact unless a permissible basis in statute was established and relying entirely on the sole arbitrator’s finding that EMTS was “inextricably intertwined” with the investment transaction. It concluded that, having received substantial sums derived from the underlying agreements, it would be inequitable for EMTS to deny being bound by the arbitration agreement.
The extension of arbitration agreements to non-signatories is an area in which arbitration laws may diverge and reach different conclusions, even on the same set of facts. The Kabab-Ji cases, which involved proceedings before French and English courts regarding an award rendered in Paris, illustrate this position.
Kabab-Ji involved franchise agreements governed by English law, which provided for ICC arbitration in Paris. The Paris-seated tribunal issued an award against a non-signatory, Kout Food Group (KFG). It found that, under French law, which applied to the arbitration agreement as the law of the seat (in the absence of a specific designation to the contrary), the existence and validity of an arbitration agreement is to be assessed by reference to the intention of the parties in the circumstances of the case, rather than through the application of any national law standards. On that basis, the tribunal held that the facts supported the extension of the arbitration agreement to KFG.
KFG sought to annul the award in Paris and challenged its enforcement in the United Kingdom on the basis that it was not a party to the arbitration agreement.
It should be noted that the UK Supreme Court's decision preceded reforms to the English Arbitration Act 1996 which came into effect last year and might, if decided today, have resulted in the application of French law by the English courts.
The Judgment confirms that Nigerian law will, in appropriate cases, extend arbitration agreements and awards to non-signatories whose conduct shows a clear connection to the underlying agreement. Contracting parties to arbitration agreements governed by Nigerian law should therefore consider at the outset which affiliated entities may be exposed to arbitration and enforcement risk, particularly given the Court’s facts-first approach.
7 September 2026